Style: progressive/depressive rock/metal
Thoughts: "You would never sleep at night, if you knew what I've been through." A strong proclamation from the first song on Tonight's Decision - For My Demons. The second album where the band switched from their doom/black/death roots into a more rock oriented focus.
Discouraged Ones was more or less a continuation of the Brave Murder Day style with a more verse/chorus structure. The riffs largely remained consistent with the single note picked riffs that were repetitive and yet still somehow hypnotic and compelling. Tonight's Decision begins to move away from that style rather decisively.
The simple note picked riffs are still present throughout the album, such as in the verse for I Am Nothing and in moments of For My Demons. There are other parts of these same songs though where the band starts going for a more open chord approach that kind of goes half way between a wall of sound effect and the earlier albums.
With all these songs though the lead guitar has a lot more of a role than it did since the debut Dance of December Souls. It weaves back and fourth with the vocals as if almost in an interplay or delicate dance. Sometimes its awkward, sometimes it works so well that it offers some of Katatonia's best moments in their extensive catalog.
It's the awkward moments where this album starts to lose me though. Songs like I am Nothing and In Death, A Song there are just too many points where I feel like the riffs/leads needed a bit more time to ruminate with the band to sound a little less rough. This isn't just prevalent in these early songs, it's in nearly every song, at least for a few moments. It's hard to get past them as they will break up the flow before the band goes back to grooving.
I kind of get what the band was going for here. They were trying to find their sound after transitioning out of extreme metal. This is very much a transition album as the band would find their true sound post-extremity with the follow up. This album is in some ways their awkward teenage years before they finally show all of the potential that they have been hinting at for years.
























