Style: black metal with gothic influences
Thoughts: What a wild ride. An album that I've been listening to nearly my entire life is not the initial version of that album, but a re-recording.
Apparently Cradle wanted to get off their current label and so they abandoned the recording of their second album before it was released. This same album was then re-recorded for Music For Nations and was released shortly thereafter. This became the classic (and my personal favorite) Cradle album: Dusk and Her Embrace.
It's so ironic then that I have the original version of this album in my collection and I don't have the Music for Nations one (re-release that one, seriously MfN). Needless to say, this is still Dusk, but in a different form. The same songs are present here for the most part (Malice Through the Looking Glass is missing), and there are multiple songs and interludes that were not present on the MfN version.
So the same songs are present, but how similar are they? Well... pretty close for the most part. They are a bit rougher production wise and the synths aren't as clear as they are on the re-recording, but overall it's pretty similar. Is it better or worse tho? I think that's a matter of personal taste. For me it's a different take on the best album the band released.
So the biggest difference here is Dani's voice. He has a much scratchier vocal delivery here and only uses his trademark howls from time to time. They fit the music very well, but sound much more standard black metalish than what you would normally hear from the band.
The production I actually find to be more enjoyable on this release than I do on the re-recording. The muddier production fits the music a bit better than the squeaky clean production on the re-recording. It gives the music a bit of a grittier edge and as a result amps the intensity of these excellent riffs up just a tad bit more.
I also like the synths being a little less defined. You can still hear them clearly but they are not as well produced or as clear in what instrument they are mimicking on this release. That ambiguity is awesome and adds to the more obscure atmosphere that this album provides over the alternative.Listen to the end of the title track. It's way more intense than the re-recording and the production amplifies this up to another level that the re-recording simply does not have.
There are parts to the counter point though as well. A Gothic Romance lacks the powerful lead guitars that the re-recording has. I can't tell if they are there or obscured, or if they just weren't in this version of the song.
So there are some parts that are powerful, and other parts that are lacking. Regardless this is still an amazing black metal album. Possibly the last time you could truly call them black metal without going more into the gothic metal realm.
These riffs are as intense now as they ever were and this is the first full album where Cradle showed what they could truly do. It doesn't matter what version, this or the re-recording - these songs kick all sorts of ass. Essential listening.

























