Style: melodic death metal
Primary Emotions/Themes: modern day, religion, the human condition
Thoughts: In Flames is a very important band. Not only are they critical in my musical taste in metal, but they helped define what I look for in a lot of music beyond the genre. The band came into my life at a critical time... I was deciding if I was going to move on from metal or if I was going to delve deeper into it. I was heavily into the alternative metal scene at the time and had little to no interest in any form of extreme metal... until I heard Dark Tranquillity and In Flames.
Dark Tranquillity's history is chronicled elsewhere, but In Flames deserves as much credit as Dark Tranquillity. Dark Tranquillity started the shift in me from nu-metal to the more extreme styles in the genre, but I was still wary. There was only one band in the style that was to my liking.
I heard a lot of people mention In Flames in the same breath as Dark Tranquillity more than once. I had my local store order Whoracle and well... yeah that was all I needed. This melodic death metal thing was exactly what I was looking for in music. I was hooked.
I quickly ordered as much as I possibly could and found the rest at Tower Records. Teenage me was very happy. A few years later I was completely enamored with the band and heard that they had a new album coming out soon - this one called Clayman. I was excited, maybe more so than any other album I had been in a while. Colony was great and this was coming out a year after that. I picked it up day one.
The first thing I noticed before I even put the CD in my player was that the titled were... different. The more esoteric song titles were gone, in their place we had more modern song titles. I wasn't sure what I thought about that, but ya know as long as the music is good who cares right?
Well I put the album on and Bullet Ride started. The opening riff is great, it builds anticipation for whats about to happen, it even reminded me a bit of some Whoracle themes. I got even more excited. The band strips back the distortion and Anders started his semi crone/talk vocals. These were nothing new, he had done this a ton on Whoracle. Not the biggest fan but whatever. So far so good... then came the chorus.
Anders' growl... if you can call it that was weak. It was like he was yelling in a whiny tone with a bit of distortion on it. It had gone up quite a few registers since colony and all of the power that I loved from his vocals was completely gone. When he got to the second or third line of "Turning, twisting the alphabet" he goes down to the lower register so I knew he could do the classic Anders... but outside of that one line he didn't do it... Why?
The song continued, maybe this was just a thing for Bullet Ride. Well, Pinball Map came on and Only For the Weak, and Square Nothing, and... nope this was his new vocal style. What the hell was happening? The music still was classic In Flames. The riffs were fucking amazing, but holy shit those vocals, what was he thinking?
I hated it. It ruined the album for me. I made it through once then turned it off. Not worth my time. I went back to listening to Jester Race and Colony that same day and never wanted to listen to it again. I would go back to it a few more times but ultimately the vocals killed it for me. The band was not dead to me, but I did not like the direction that they were headed.
I think I stopped playing the record for years. I would sometimes go back to listen to the title track which still remains an amazing In Flames song but most of the album was lacking that spark that I loved so much from the first four albums. This was essentially my thoughts on Clayman for decades. Then the vinyl re-release was announced recently.
I forced myself to listen to the album in its entirety for the first time in years... maybe decades. What I heard was a different album. Yes, Anders vocals still suck, but you know what I can get past that. What I heard was a band that was playing classic In Flames riffs without even trying (unlike recent outings from the band). The band was in their prime here and it shows. These melodies are vintage In Flames and I was a fool for ignoring that part of the album for so long.
In Flames absolutely have started to experiment with their sound on Clayman, much more so than any of the first four albums. Satellites and Astronauts shows the band incorporating a lot of electronic elements, the aforementioned Bullet Ride does the same during one of the verses. Anders' is experimenting more with clean vocals than ever before. Honestly it sounds like the band is starting to get bored of their classic sound and is putting out feelers for what direction to go.
A lot of people will point to the follow up to this album as the first transition album to what In Flames would ultimately become. I think that the transition started here. Clayman is a transition album for the band. They still have their riffs and focus but there is a LOT of experimentation on the album with mixed results. Is it a great album? No not really. Is it better than I remember? Hell yes it is.
























